How to Turn Amazon Prime Day(s) into Long-Term Wins: Strategies for Building Customer Loyalty

How to Turn Amazon Prime Day(s) into Long-Term Wins: Strategies for Building Customer Loyalty

Every July, shoppers flood digital storefronts in search of the best deals — and not just on Amazon. What began as a single-platform promotion in 2015 has snowballed into a summer-long sales phenomenon across the retail industry. With Prime Day 2025 expected to expand to four full days, brands of all sizes face a familiar question: how can we compete — and win — during the summer’s most competitive e-commerce window?

The answer lies not in flash sales alone, but in how brands use this period to acquire high-value customers who return long after the sale ends. For businesses focused on long-term growth, July offers more than just a revenue spike — it’s a valuable opportunity to build relationships.

Strategies for Prime Day Wins

Prime Day’s Broader Impact on Retail Strategy

Prime Day and its evolution have results rivaling Black Friday. In 2024 alone, retail sales during Prime Day week topped $14.2 billion. This momentum reflects a shift in consumer behavior: shoppers now expect—and actively seek—deals in July, regardless of the platform.

This shift presents more than a sales opportunity. It’s a strategic moment to engage new audiences, elevate brand presence, and create memorable shopping experiences that extend far beyond a single transaction.

Know Your Customers’ Long-Term Value

The first step in crafting a July sales strategy that builds brand loyalty is understanding customer lifetime value (LTV). LTV estimates the total revenue a customer will generate over the life of their relationship with your brand, and it should be the cornerstone of your summer promotions strategy.

Products such as skincare, supplements, baby clothing, and other consumables tend to attract high-LTV customers, as purchases are frequent and repeatable. In contrast, one-time purchases, such as mattresses or engagement rings, generally offer less opportunity for repeat transactions.

For brands with strong LTV potential, Prime Day presents an opportunity to attract new customers. A well-timed discount may hurt margins in the short term, but it’s a worthwhile investment if it brings in customers who will return month after month.

Planning for Long-Term Growth, Not Just Short-Term Revenue

If your business sells high-repeat items or has strong cross-sell potential, your Prime Day strategy should focus on more than just the depth of discounts.

Strategies for Prime Day Wins

Consider how your offers support:

  • Customer acquisition goals: Prioritize new customers that align with your strongest audience segments.
  • Data collection: Leverage increased traffic to build your email list and retargeting pools.
  • Brand trust: Ensure a seamless buying experience that leaves customers eager to return.

On the other hand, businesses with low-repeat products may use Prime Day more tactically — to clear inventory, move discontinued SKUs, or generate awareness during a high-traffic window.

How to Stand Out Without Slashing Prices

Strategies for Prime Day Wins

With nearly every retailer competing for attention, standing out during Prime Day requires more than just markdowns. Consumers are increasingly wary of sales that feel like inventory dumps. Instead, focus on promotions that deliver:

  • Real value: Feature your bestsellers, bundles, or newly launched items — not just closeouts.
  • Brand alignment: Maintain consistency in the customer experience and product presentation with your year-round standards.
  • Retention strategy: Follow up post-sale with personalized messaging, loyalty incentives, or product education that encourages re-engagement.

Smart Strategies for a Complex Economic Climate

2025’s Prime Day landscape may be shaped by rising advertising costs and economic uncertainty, including new tariff impacts. Brands should prepare with:

Strategies for Prime Day Wins
  • Flexible pricing models: Weigh the pros and cons of absorbing increased costs, raising prices, or shifting promotion to tariff-free products.
  • Real-time competitive monitoring: Track how your competitors adjust prices and ad spend in the weeks before Prime Day.
  • Ad budget planning: Expect increased cost-per-click (CPC) rates on Meta and Google, and decide whether to compete or hold back.

Even brands that opt out of Prime Day promotions entirely should have a strategy. Without discounts to entice buyers, you may want to pause ads temporarily or focus on brand-building rather than conversions.

The Takeaway: Prime Day Is a Springboard, Not a Silo

Prime Day is no longer just a date on the retail calendar — it’s a cultural moment that drives significant traffic and purchase intent. But the real winners in July won’t just be those who offer the deepest discounts. They’ll be the brands that use the moment to connect with customers who keep coming back.

By grounding your strategy in LTV, preparing for economic shifts, and focusing on the post-sale experience, you can turn July deal-seekers into loyal customers who fuel your growth year-round.

David Johnson

David Johnson, Vice President of Agency Growth

David Johnson is the Vice President of Agency Growth at Logical Position, bringing over a decade of expertise in enterprise marketing. Known for his strategic vision and execution of high-impact initiatives, David consistently drives success for top-tier clients. A thought leader in the industry, he’s a go-to authority on paid media strategies. When he’s not crafting winning campaigns, David cherishes time with his wife and child.

Logical Position

Logical Position, an Inc. 500 digital agency supporting 5,000+ clients across North America. LP is the proud recipient of Google’s Lead Generation Premier Partner of the Year and Microsoft's Global Channel Partner of the Year 2024! The award-winning agency offers full-service PPC management, SEO, Paid Social, Amazon and Creative Services for businesses large and small. As a Google Premier Partner, Microsoft Elite Partner & Meta Business Partner, LP is in the top 1% of ad spend managed across platforms.

Amazon PPC vs. Amazon SEO: Why Your Business Needs Both

Amazon Advertising

Amazon PPC vs. Amazon SEO: Why Your Business Needs Both

If you’re running a successful e-commerce business, chances are you’ve considered expanding your brand to Amazon. After all, over half of product searches begin on [...]

By: Craig Panozzo | May 5, 2025

Read More

How to Launch an Amazon Ad Campaign in Another Country

Amazon Advertising

How to Launch an Amazon Ad Campaign in Another Country

Expanding your e-commerce business beyond domestic borders can be a great way to drive new growth, increase brand visibility, or even offset seasonality. However, navigating [...]

By: Craig Panozzo | February 18, 2025

Read More

The Benefits of Amazon Customer Journey Mapping

Amazon Advertising

The Benefits of Amazon Customer Journey Mapping

In the labyrinth of e-commerce, mapping out a customer’s entire experience can sometimes feel like an impossible task. However, if you break it up into [...]

By: Brooke Natenson | November 20, 2024

Read More

Join the 7,000+ Companies Using Logical Position

Smarter Marketing Straight to Your Inbox

Want to keep up with what’s working in digital marketing? Sign up for ideas, advice, and industry updates you can actually use.